Research Article
The article I chose is the Key to Teaching the Nature of Science by William F. McComas. This article talks about the Nine core Nature of Science (NOS) Ideas. I have listed them below:
- Science demands and relies on empirical evidence
- Science should required data which is reviewed by others. This data should justify all final conclusions.
- Ideas begin as "exploratory notions"
- Can not be dismissed immediately unless there is significant evidence stating otherwise.
- "The requirement for empirical evidence is accompanied by the caution that not all evidence is gained through experimental means, although that is frequently called the "gold standard" of science".
- Science relies on basic observations
- Scientists use a combination of methods such as:
- historical
- observational
- experimental
- Science is and must remain an "empirical data-driven pursuit.
- Knowledge production in science includes many common features and shared habits of mind. However, in spite of such commonalities there is no single step-by-step scientific method by which all science is done.
- Logical reasoning and data collection are essential to science
- However, there is no universal way
- "Studies of scientists at work reveal many idiosyncratic ways of approaching research and even coming up with research in the first place"
- Scientific knowledge is tentative but durable. This means that science cannot prove anything because the problem of induction makes "proof; impossible, but scientific conclusions are still valuable and long lasting because if the way that knowledge eventually comes to be accepted in science".
- `"Induction is the knowledge generation process by which individual data points related to the problem or phenomenon are gathered until a general trend, principle or law emerges from this mass of data"
- Prediction and deduction are essentials, as they are used to determine the validity of the conclusion.
- There is no way to determine whether the statement is true, only time can tell.
- Laws and theories are related but distinct kinds of scientific knowledge.
- Misconception: Science is laws of mature theories and laws are more valuable than these theories.
- Laws and theories are equally important
- Laws: generalizations or patterns in nature
- Theories: explanations for why laws hold
- Science is a highly creative endeavor
- Scientists agree that their work is creative
- inspiration leads to the creation of science
- We have to teach students that science is not just facts
- they should explore the world of science
- Studies show that students will reject the field of science as a career because they had no opportunity to explore or see the creativity it implies
- Science has a subjective element
- Science is subjective
- People respond and evaluate data in different ways
- Therefore, ideas, data and conclusions must be peer reviewed in order to be published
- Acts as a checks and balances system
- There are historical, cultural and social influence on science
- Research may favor certain aspects or these aspects may favor certain research
- May be controversial
- These aspects may impede or support the research
- Science and technology impact each other, but they are not the same
- Topics are technological in nature or scientific in nature
- Technological topics are often "applied science"
- Science in natural are "pure science"
- Science and its methods cannot answer all questions
- There are limits to science
- can not explain the opinions of people
- Avoid the common but false idea that science and religion are at war
- Important: Science cannot and should not answer all questions
Comments
Post a Comment